Just read Melvyn Burgess's 'Doing it'. I've read two of his previous books: 'Junk' about teenage heroin addiction; and 'Lady: My Life as a Bitch' about a girl who gets ... turned into a dog. I loved them both and thought they were both brave and brilliantly written. After reading the Children's Laureate, Anne Fine's, disgusted review of 'Doing it' in the Guardian, I had to read the book. (Read The Guardian's own review here.) The bits she quotes are pretty disgusting. But they are also the worst bits of the book. And, what she doesn't know or doesn't believe, is that this is how teenage boys (and not just teenage boys, I've heard grown men come out with much worse) talk. In fact, Burgess flatters them:
'Jon leaned across to Ben.
"The rustling of nipples stiffening against the poly-cotton pads of a thousand Wonderbras. The gentle hiss of a roomful of drenching gussets," he said.'
Don't think 17 year old boys are that articulate, but I'm sure they'd appreciate the sentiment.
But then I can kind of see Anne Fine's point about it demeaning women. The female characters, apart from Deborah, are mostly unbalanced. And Deborah's fat so none of the boys fancies her (although she does say that plenty of boys outside the school do). Fine said that she wouldn't want girls to read this about themselves. But this is how a lot of men are. It's sad, but it's true. And I think (although I'm not sure) that I'd rather know. Then again, I hate to think of teenage boys reading this and thinking it's cool.
I'm not at all comfortable with the suggestion that the book should be pulped, though. If we go down that route, who decides? But then, when I read 'American Psycho' for university, I had the same thought. There is stuff in 'American Psycho' far worse than anything in 'Doing It', and the get-out clause is that it's probably fantasy. As is 'Doing It' (proven by the student's affair with the teacher - what 17 year old boy hasn't thought of that?).
Basically ... I don't know. I don't think it's a good book. I don't think it's particularly well-written. Once you've read the dirty bits, it's a bit boring. Unlike Anne Fine, I don't think it will damage the fabric of our society. But ... if this is the way things are going, if this is what books for boys are going to be like, I wouldn't be happy. And it could, eventually, make a difference.