Behold! A new Chicklish category! Welcome to the first Chick-Chat Review* - a book-related conversation between two or more Chicklish reviewers. And the first subject of this brand new exercise? None other than Meg Cabot's recently released Princess Diaries book 9, which in the UK is called To The Nines. (You can read extracts here and here.)
*Name subject to change if everyone thinks it's rubbish! Also note that Vulpes Libris has been doing this style of review for a while. :)
Here goes...
CHICK-CHAT REVIEW: Princess Diaries To The Nines by Meg Cabot
Alexandra: So, I KNOW you read it first (so unfair!) but I’ve now finished it too and I’m dying to know what you thought of it?
Luisa: I loved it! I love the whole series, of course, but I thought this was a particularly strong book. I feel sorry for Mia, but she's growing up, things are changing for her and the people in her life. There were bound to be stormy times ahead in her relationships with Michael and Lilly, really...
Alexandra: I couldn’t figure out if I was glad about the fall out with Lilly. I think I was as she was getting really annoying.
Luisa: I agree, she was, although I had to keep reminding myself that I was only seeing everything from Mia's point of view! I can see how Lilly would be annoyed about JP, and doubly annoyed for the sake of her brother. She's not the most touchy-feely person at the best of times, so... Yes, I can see why she wasn't talking to Mia. I do feel sorry for Mia, though. What can you do when someone just won't listen to your side of things? I'm so glad she has Tina! I love Tina.
Luisa: So, who do you think is right for Mia: JP, Michael or someone else?
Alexandra: Hmmm, I don’t know – maybe someone else. I worry J.P. might be a bit too ‘stalky’, I mean, she said she needed time, he said he’d wait, but he kept appearing at her apartment! I agree with what you just said on Lilly. She should be annoyed at J.P. and, to be a bit of a Tina here: it was clear that he went out with Lilly to be closer to Mia. So that makes me worry about if he would let Mia down? And does he like Mia because he has a dad who expects him to live up to certain things? But, on the other hand, his own notoriety means he ‘gets’ a lot of what she goes through, doesn’t he? Like the limelight stuff and he is really cute taking her to musicals! Don’t get me started on Michael – well, he’s a bit stupid, isn’t he? He should have told her the whole Judith Gershner thing. ARGH. Boys….!!!!!
Luisa: It's true that JP seems a better match for Mia on paper, which could be offputting - I mean, I can see that Mia might be uncomfortable with it. She's not one to do things for the sake of appearances, is she? But there are some genuine feelings between them, too. I think he's a sweet character. He's more in touch with his feminine side than Michael, isn't he? LOL. Hmm. Mind you, I don't think Mia's going to get over Michael in a hurry.
Luisa: D'you know what? It's odd to think that Mia used to go out with Kenny, however briefly!
Alexandra: So tell me, that thing Kenny does in the lab (that we shouldn’t give too much away about), do you think he did it deliberately? Like he’s smart isn’t he, so….
Luisa: Ooh, I hadn't thought of that! No, surely not. I'll tell you what, though - that was such a funny moment. I'm laughing to myself just thinking about the way that was built up!
Alexandra: It was almost as funny as the fact Kenny now has muscles!!!
Luisa: So what did you think of the book overall?
Alexandra: Brilliant. I love the way the Princess Diaries are not like those series where you think, “I will not read the next one as they’re all the same.” This was really great, both as the next in the series and on its own. And I like the grown-up feel, now that she’s older, and I the ending is fab too. But we can’t talk about that can we?
Luisa: S'pose not. But I agree with you! :)
Alexandra: How long do we have to wait for the next one? I’m going to go into denial that it’s the last one. How will I cope otherwise?
Luisa: I don't know when the last one's out (nooooo!) but I'm guessing some time next year. I'll keep an eye on Meg Cabot's site and report back with news. And I agree with you about it being the last one - how will we cope? Let's hope there are spin-offs and, of course, other fab Meg books to look forward to!